As with many Nikon users taking a serious look at this Tamron G2 lens and the Nikon FL, I researched to gain insight as to relative performance of these two lenses, deciding whether or not I should go with the $1300 Tamron or fork up the $2800 for the new Nikon E FL, anticipating that I would not buy another 70-200 f/2.8 for years to come.
As an aside, I own an A7RII and an A6500, for which I have some of the best glass. The 90mm macro and 55 f/1.8 are razor sharp lenses, by the way. I was willing to buy the 70-200 Master ($2600), for which I would use to shoot/video action in low light conditions. But that lens on those two top-of-the-line Sony bodies has way too many autofocus issues. The Sony 70-200GMaster, which I tested, is pretty sharp, but what use is a 2.8 telephoto that can't focus in low light conditions? You're better off just getting the Sony 70-200 f/4, which, given the Sony 70-200 f/2.8's poor low light performance, would basically give you the same performance in a lighter less expensive body. I just throw my 55f/1.8 and zoom by foot to cover the 70-100mm range on my A6500 and throw the 90mm macro on the same to cover the 130+ range. Remember, the 200mm on the Sony 70-200mm is more like a 150mm due to focus breathing. In any case, due its poor low light performance, the Sony was disqualified, even though I prefer Sony for still photography and video.
Back to the Tamron 70-200 G2 and the 70-200mm Nikon E FL:
I went to a local camera store which sells and rents all the top-of-the-line lenses. There I hooked up the 70-200mm Nikon FL to my Nikon D750.
To my 20-15 pixel-peeping eyes, the Nikon FL seems to have slightly, and I mean SLIGHTLY, better sharpness wide open in the center of the frame and better magnification--i.e., less focus breathing. While in the store, I took dozens upon dozens of wide open photos at 70, 85, 100, 130, 170, and 200mm and compared them in Lightroom to photos of the 70-200mm Tamron G2 and the Sony 70-200mm GMaster, which I only attached to my A6500. I understand the Master would have been sharper on my A7RII, but both cameras use the latest versions of 24mp+- CMOS sensors, making the comparisons somewhat on par, I guesstimate. Plus, the poor focusing of the Sony, which was validated on my A6500, disqualifies that lens for action photography or other forms of low light photography.
IMHO, the new Nikon FL, which I was willing to buy in a split second were it as sharp as some say, is not worth $1500 more than the Tamron G2. I wouldn't pay $1800 for that lens, especially now that I've tested the Tamron G2, which is basically the SAME LENS. REALLY. For its slight increase in center sharpness and decrease in focus breathing, the new Nikon may be worth $250 more, IMO, as the slight edge in center sharpness is truly negligible. In fact, I would have instantly either suffered from buyers remorse after purchasing the Nikon FL or rationalized/validated the purchase of it by convincing myself that its worth every penny to suppress buyers remorse. That lens is not worth $3000 and neither is the Sony 70-200 GMaster. If the Tamron were not as good as the Nikon, then the Nikon may be worth $3k; but the Tamron is as good as the Nikon, maybe even better, if you look at the totality of the lens, not just it's center sharpness.
Let me tell you why.
The Tamron SP 70-200 G2 is just as sharp. I tell you no lie. But that's more or less to be expected. IMO, all the 70-200 f/2,8 and F/4's are pretty much as sharp as the other. You have to really pixel peep to see the difference. Where they distinguish themselves is in their low light performance--wide open. That's what you pay the big bucks for.
What is good low light performance on a lens? It's the ability to quickly find focus in low light conditions. The camera is responsible for the ISO performance, not the lens. And when it comes to the low light performance of the Tamron G2: Absolutely Awesome Low Light Performance.
On my D750, the Tamron G2 acquires focus instantaneously. To be fair, the Nikon FL acquired focus instantaneously on my D750, as well. Both the Tamron G2 and the Nikon FL acquire focus instantaneously on my D750. It is truly truly remarkable. Having said that, the Tamron does so for $1500 less.
It's sort of like clothes shopping. The name brand item is better than the generic brand, 90% of the time. But sometimes it isn't. In this case, the name brand Nikon is only slightly better than the reverse-engineered Tamron, but the difference is truly negligible, unless you pixel peep on Lightroom in 100% crop mode. And that's only in the very center of the frame, looking at an eyelash or the microscopic hairs on the persons nose. Fresh out-of-the-box, my Tamron G2 instantly focuses on anything I point it at, less a plain white wall or some other contrast-less thing. But all lenses do that. And no, I did not hook up the Tap-in-Console to achieve that level of focus acquisition.
In a nutshell, the sharpness, focus acquisition, lens stabilization, seeming build quality, and warranty of the two lenses is virtually identical. The Nikon is lighter, seems to be a tad bit brighter, and the focus rings are smoother, but that's it. $1500 more for that? Not me.
Instead of paying about $3k for the Nikon or Sony, I bought the Tamron G2 and the D750--all brand new for $3100 or the same price you will pay if you buy the Nikon locally and pay tax.
If you buy online, make sure to buy from a reputable dealer like Amazon, B&H, or Adorama. I wouldn't risk any open-box or used copies of any of these lenses, given the QC issues reported.
What's more, both lenses are said to have quality control issues. However, both lenses come with extended warranties, and Tamron even went so far as to develop a Tap-in Console, enabling fine-tunings.
I highly recommend the Tamron SP 70-200mm G2.
Update:
The lens is still performing very well, and I received a $200 Rebate check from Tamron because I qualified for the Student Rebate, per the Tamron Website.
Add to your order
-
Coverage for accidental damage including drops, spills, and broken parts, as well as breakdowns (plans vary) -
24/7 support when you need it. -
Quick, easy, and frustration-free claims.
Cover this product:
2-Year Protection $99.99
3-Year Protection $129.99
Cover all of your eligible devices:
Asurion Complete Protect: One plan covers all eligible past and future purchases (Renews Monthly Until Cancelled) $16.99/month
Select a plan
Add to your order
- Coverage for accidental damage including drops, spills, and broken parts, as well as breakdowns (plans vary)
- 24/7 support when you need it.
- Quick, easy, and frustration-free claims.
Cover this product:
Select a plan
Buy this product as Renewed and save $434.05 off the current New price.
Tamron SP 70-200mm F/2.8 Di VC G2 for Nikon FX Digital SLR Camera (Renewed) $864.95 & FREE Shipping
(18)
Works and looks like new and backed by the Amazon Renewed Guarantee
(18)
Works and looks like new and backed by the Amazon Renewed Guarantee
Add a debit or credit card to save time when you check out
Convenient and secure with 2 clicks. Add your card
Consider a similar item
$979.99
Climate Pledge Friendly Frequently bought together
$1,299.00
Get it as soon as Friday, May 17
Only 10 left in stock (more on the way).
+
Total price:
To see our price, add these items to your cart.
Choose items to buy together.
Similar items that may deliver to you quickly
Page 1 of 1 Start overPage 1 of 1
Climate Pledge FriendlyProducts with trusted sustainability certification(s). Learn morePRODUCT CERTIFICATION (1)
Pre-owned Certified: Electronics products are inspected, cleaned and (if applicable) repaired to excellent functional standards. Buying Pre-owned extends a product's life, reducing e-waste and raw material extraction.
Climate Pledge FriendlyProducts with trusted sustainability certification(s). Learn morePRODUCT CERTIFICATION (1)
Pre-owned Certified: Electronics products are inspected, cleaned and (if applicable) repaired to excellent functional standards. Buying Pre-owned extends a product's life, reducing e-waste and raw material extraction.
Compare with similar items
This Item  Tamron SP 70-200mm F/2.8 Di VC G2 for Nikon FX DSLR (6 Year Limited USA Warranty for New Lenses Only) |  |  |  |  |  | |
| Price | $1,299.00 | $1,379.00 | -61% $979.99 New Price: $2,490.00 | -33% $869.00 New Price: $1,299.00 | -25% $1,049.95 New Price: $1,399.00 | $1,198.50 |
| Delivery | Get it as soon as Friday, May 17 | Get it as soon as Wednesday, May 15 | — | Get it as soon as Monday, May 13 | — | Get it as soon as Monday, May 13 |
| Customer Ratings | ||||||
| Image stabilization | ||||||
| Auto focus | ||||||
| Picture quality | ||||||
| Sold By | Amazon.com | ThePixelConnection | Xpress Products (We track Serial Numbers) | Minty Gadgets (we track serial numbers) | Electronics Basket | Minty Gadgets (we track serial numbers) |
| lens type | Telephoto | Telephoto | Telephoto | Telephoto | Telephoto | Telephoto |
| compatible mountings | Nikon F (FX) | Nikon F | Nikon F (FX) | Nikon F (FX) | Nikon F (FX) | Nikon F |
| lens design | Zoom | Prime | Zoom | Zoom | Zoom | Zoom |
| focus type | Auto Focus | Auto Focus | Ring-type ultrasonic | Auto Focus | Auto Focus | Manual Focus, Auto Focus |
| minimum focal length | — | 70 millimeters | 70 millimeters | — | 150 millimeters | 70 millimeters |
| max focal length | — | 200 millimeters | 200 millimeters | — | 600 millimeters | 200 millimeters |
| fixed focal length | 200 millimeters | 200 millimeters | 200 millimeters | 200 millimeters | 600 millimeters | 200 millimeters |
| model name | AFA025N700 | AFA025N-700 | — | vc g2,vc usd g2 | vc usd g2 | 2185 |
From the manufacturer
Expand your image of fast telephoto shooting
The new SP70-200mm F/2.8 G2 (Model A025) telephoto lens reimagines the highly acclaimed Model A009 with enhanced optical performance, improved VC (Vibration Compensation), faster AF speed and accuracy, and shortened MOD (Minimum Object Distance) for greater flexibility. What’s more, compatibility with optional Tamron teleconverters provides additional focal length. In keeping with the SP series’ innovative technology, the lens is designed to be durable, flexible and resilient enough to rise to any occasion.
High resolution meets beautiful bokeh
Every aspect of the SP 70-200mm F/2.8 G2 (Model A025) zoom has been improved, providing high image quality and enhanced bokeh throughout. Optical design features include XLD (eXtra Low Dispersion) and LD (Low Dispersion) glass to eliminate chromatic aberrations across the entire zoom range, ensuring optimum resolution— even at the edges. eBAND Coating designed exclusively for this new zoom offers superior anti- reflection properties, greatly minimizing flare and ghosting. And refined bokeh provides spectacular background effects from nearly any angle.
MOD reduced to 0.95m
Improvements to the new SP 70-200mm F/2.8 G2 extend well into the lens barrel. Tamron has reduced the MOD from 1.3m (50.7 in) in our older model to 0.95m (37.4 in), allowing a maximum magnification ratio of 1:6.1. The shorter MOD, coupled with the superb optical performance of this new zoom, allows you to significantly broaden your range of expression.
Accuracy in action
The USD (Ultrasonic Silent Drive) ring-type motor, along with two high-performance microcomputers, ensures excellent focusing speed and accuracy. The Full-time Manual Focus override allows you to make fine adjustments while using AF, without having to switch from AF to MF mode.
Keep it steady with VC equal to 5 stops
Tamron’s best VC* image stabilization performance is equivalent to 5 stops**, according to CIPA standards. Plus, this lens offers a choice of three VC modes, including one exclusively for panning. Now you can match the VC mode to your shooting conditions and enjoy sharp, jitter-free handheld shooting—even in low light. * Among 70-200mm F/2.8 interchangeable lenses for full-frame DSLR cameras. (As of January, 2017. Source: Tamron.) ** Using in VC MODE 3 For Canon: 5D-MKIII is used For Nikon: D810 is used
Videos
Page 1 of 1Start OverPage 1 of 1
Videos for this product
1:17
Click to play video
Awesome Tamron telephoto lens (review)
Should I Get It Reviews
Videos for this product
4:17
Click to play video
Super capable lens for portraits and sports
Should I Get It Reviews
Reviews with images
Have not used it enough for a quality review.
I got this lens as a general wal around lens. I am pleased but the weather here has been to hard to get out.
Top reviews from the United States
There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.
Top reviews from other countries
Alexandre Nogueira
Espetacular!
Reviewed in Brazil on November 23, 2022Set: Lens OnlyVerified Purchase
Marcus S
Superb piece of kit.
Reviewed in Canada on September 29, 2017Set: Lens OnlyVerified Purchase
Jeanine
I love this lens.
Reviewed in Canada on February 9, 2020Set: Lens OnlyVerified Purchase
Jeanine
Reviewed in Canada on February 9, 2020
Images in this review
